Cricket
Racing
Rugby
League
Motorsport
Football
Golf
Combat Sports
Basketball
Tennis
Other Sports
Sport Nation
A Calf Strain Isn’t Just a Niggle — It’s the Injury That’s Plaguing the AFL and NRL
SEN • May 16th, 2025 5:56 pm
This content is provided by a third party
The "Soft-Tissue Curse" Nobody’s Talking About
It’s become the most frustrating subplot of the AFL and NRL seasons — the star player who’s finally back from injury, only to be ruled out again the following week. And it’s not a knee, not a hamstring. It’s a calf strain. Again.
Just ask Geelong fans how they felt watching Patrick Dangerfield limp off after another flare-up in April. Or look at Fremantle’s Nat Fyfe, whose ongoing battle with calf issues has been more drawn-out than some players’ entire careers. This isn’t just bad luck — it’s starting to feel like an epidemic.
Soft-tissue injuries have always haunted footy, but calf strains have earned a particularly nasty reputation lately. They’re sneaky. They can seem minor. And worst of all? They love making a comeback, just when a player thinks they’re in the clear.
No one’s saying an ACL tear isn’t serious, but at least you know where you stand with a ligament rupture. A calf strain, on the other hand, can clear up just enough to give a false sense of recovery, until it doesn’t. And for elite athletes under pressure to get back on the field, that can be a brutal trap.
So why is this injury suddenly the one haunting club medics across the country? Why are experienced players, with access to world-class care, still falling victim to the same recurring strain?
Let’s break down why calf injuries have become the AFL and NRL’s soft-tissue curse — and why they're so hard to shake.
Let’s break down why calf injuries have become the AFL and NRL’s soft-tissue curse — and why they're so hard to shake.
Why the Calf Is the Achilles' Heel of Modern Footy
You’d be forgiven for thinking the calf is a simple muscle group — after all, it’s just the bit that tightens when you run, right? But in elite-level sport, the calf is doing a whole lot more than that. It’s absorbing impact, generating power, stabilising movement, and acting as the springboard for everything from burst acceleration to explosive jumping. In the AFL and NRL, where players are constantly stopping, starting, sidestepping, and sprinting, the calf is working overtime.
That workload has a price. The 2024 AFL season alone has already seen multiple veterans pulled from matches or missing weeks due to calf issues, and not all of them have returned on time. The NRL hasn’t fared any better, with high-profile names quietly disappearing from match-day squads due to “tightness” that turns into a multi-week absence.
It’s especially common in players over 30. Not because they’ve lost form or fitness, but because age naturally decreases muscle elasticity and recovery speed. Add in condensed fixture lists, high training loads, and limited time between games, and you’ve got a recipe for repetitive soft-tissue breakdown.
But the worst part? Most of these injuries don’t come with a dramatic moment. No loud pop, no awkward landing. Just a tightening, a tweak, a little niggle. The kind that makes players think they can push through — and often do, until it flares up worse than before.
That’s what makes calf injuries so dangerous. They’re subtle until they’re serious. And by the time a scan shows anything concrete, it’s usually too late.
That’s what makes calf injuries so dangerous. They’re subtle until they’re serious. And by the time a scan shows anything concrete, it’s usually too late.
The Comeback Pressure That Makes It Worse
In a perfect world, athletes would only return to the field when their bodies were 100% ready. But we all know that’s not how elite sport works.
When a key midfielder or playmaker goes down with a calf strain, the countdown to their return starts before they’ve even left the field. Coaches want their stars back. Fans expect quick comebacks. The media ramps up the pressure. And the players themselves? They’re wired to compete, not to sit on the sidelines and play it safe.
The result? Calf injuries that seem minor get rushed. A player completes a few training drills, the pain’s gone, the physios clear them — and then bang. Another strain. Another few weeks out.
Dr Dave Hellyer of Seaview Health Group says this happens far too often because a calf strain can feel deceptively healed.
Dr Dave Hellyer of Seaview Health Group says this happens far too often because a calf strain can feel deceptively healed.
“It’s one of the few injuries where the pain goes away quickly, but the underlying tissue is still weak,” he explains. “If players return to sprinting and change-of-direction work too soon, they’re essentially putting that muscle back under the exact stress that caused the injury in the first place.”
Clubs are getting smarter with load management, but the timeline for recovery still often bends under the weight of match-day urgency. And that’s where the risk really spikes.
Even with elite sports science behind them, players are still human, and when a coach gives you the nod to play in a final, you're going to say yes, tight calf or not.
But as we've seen time and time again this season, that gamble doesn’t always pay off.
Even with elite sports science behind them, players are still human, and when a coach gives you the nod to play in a final, you're going to say yes, tight calf or not.
But as we've seen time and time again this season, that gamble doesn’t always pay off.
The Dangerfield & Fyfe Effect: Real Stories of Recurrent Strains
If there’s any doubt that calf injuries are derailing careers — not just matches — look no further than two of the AFL’s biggest names: Patrick Dangerfield and Nat Fyfe.
Dangerfield, the Geelong veteran and Brownlow medallist, has faced repeated setbacks with his calves over the past two seasons. Most recently, in 2024, he was ruled out mid-game after a sudden flare-up. He’d only just returned from a similar strain weeks earlier. It was a blow for the Cats, but an even bigger one for a player known for his explosive bursts and game-breaking speed.
Dangerfield, the Geelong veteran and Brownlow medallist, has faced repeated setbacks with his calves over the past two seasons. Most recently, in 2024, he was ruled out mid-game after a sudden flare-up. He’d only just returned from a similar strain weeks earlier. It was a blow for the Cats, but an even bigger one for a player known for his explosive bursts and game-breaking speed.
Nat Fyfe’s story is no less frustrating. The dual Brownlow winner has battled more than his fair share of injuries, but calf strains have been the quiet nemesis, dragging him off the field in recent seasons. In 2023 and again in 2024, calf tightness turned into weeks on the sidelines. Each return was cautious. Each setback felt like déjà vu.
These aren’t fringe players. These are the kind of athletes who’ve built reputations on durability, resilience, and elite conditioning. They have access to the best medical teams in the business — and they’re still getting caught out by a muscle group no one paid much attention to a few years ago.
And it’s not just the AFL. NRL players — especially halves and outside backs — are just as vulnerable. The quick stop-start movements, repeated sprints, and short turnarounds make them prime candidates for soft-tissue overload. While the injuries might not make as many headlines as a syndesmosis or a shoulder reconstruction, calf strains are quietly stacking up minutes lost across the league.
It’s time we start recognising calf injuries for what they are: not just inconvenient soft-tissue tweaks, but serious performance disruptors that demand respect.
It’s time we start recognising calf injuries for what they are: not just inconvenient soft-tissue tweaks, but serious performance disruptors that demand respect.
What Amateurs Can Learn From the Pros (And Avoid Repeating)
It’s easy to watch a Dangerfield or Fyfe limp off and think, “Well, that’s elite footy — doesn’t apply to me.” But here’s the thing: if the best-conditioned athletes in the country, with round-the-clock physios and finely tuned training loads, are getting calf strains… what does that mean for your average weekend warrior?
The truth is, calf injuries are just as — if not more — common among amateur athletes. The difference is that most social players don’t have the luxury of early diagnosis, tailored rehab plans, or a cautious return-to-play schedule. More often, it’s a bit of stretching, a couple of skipped games, and then straight back into full effort, which, unsurprisingly, leads to reinjury. Hellyer says this is one of the most common mistakes he sees in amateur sport.
“If you're over 30 and you go from sitting at a desk all week to sprinting flat-out on the weekend, your calves aren't ready for that load. You’ve got to treat them like high-performance machinery — not just hope they hold up.”
“If you're over 30 and you go from sitting at a desk all week to sprinting flat-out on the weekend, your calves aren't ready for that load. You’ve got to treat them like high-performance machinery — not just hope they hold up.”
Add in poor warm-ups, a lack of mobility work, and an underestimation of soft-tissue fatigue, and it’s no wonder calf strains are a repeat offender in local leagues.
The takeaway? You don’t have to be playing at the MCG or Accor Stadium for a calf injury to throw your season off course. Whether you’re running out for footy on a Saturday or charging around at lunchtime social soccer, a bit of prevention — and proper recovery — goes a long way.
The takeaway? You don’t have to be playing at the MCG or Accor Stadium for a calf injury to throw your season off course. Whether you’re running out for footy on a Saturday or charging around at lunchtime social soccer, a bit of prevention — and proper recovery — goes a long way.
Final Take: Calf Injuries Deserve the Same Respect as a Hammy or ACL
For too long, calf strains have lived in the shadow of the big-name injuries — the torn ACLs, the hammies, the shoulders. They’re seen as minor, manageable, maybe even a bit soft. But ask any AFL or NRL player who's battled one, and you’ll hear a different story.
These aren’t just sore legs. They’re injuries that mess with your speed, your power, your movement — the very things that define a performance at the top level. And when they’re ignored or mismanaged, they come back stronger, more stubborn, and with a vengeance.
As Dr Dave Hellyer says, the biggest mistake athletes make — pro or amateur — is treating a calf strain like a short-term annoyance instead of what it really is: a serious soft-tissue injury that needs time and respect.
So what needs to change?
At the elite level, it’s about pushing back on return-to-play pressure and trusting the science, even when the calendar says “must-win match.” At the amateur level, it’s about listening to your body, doing the boring recovery work, and not trying to sprint at full pace after sitting in an office all week.
Whether you’re chasing a premiership or just chasing your kids around the backyard, the results are the same — respect the calf, or it’ll make sure you remember it.
