All Blacks' attacking deficiencies laid bare as Wales deliver Cardiff shock
Henry Lee in London • November 17th, 2026 9:09 am

Photo: Photosport
It was the inevitable win that unravelled horribly in Cardiff.
No one predicted a stunning Wales victory at the Principality Stadium, and you couldn’t have scripted it any better.
346 tackles. You are reading that right. Wales’ resilience and fearless defence was on show from the first whistle, where it was clear the All Blacks were going to be second best.
Take nothing away from Steve Tandy’s charges in red; it was a superb performance. They played with heart, desire, a never-say-die attitude, and total disregard for their bodies defensively.
Dafydd Jenkins, 40 tackles, Jac Morgan, 34, James Botham, 33, you get the picture.
Having played the majority of the second half inside the Wales 22-meter line, the All Blacks crashed and bashed their way close, but that ultimately was the biggest issue as the convincing win many predicted was thrown out the window.
The passionate Welsh defence held up All Blacks ball carriers on several occasions, but it was the way in which the All Blacks settled on pick-and-goes that will haunt Rennie and the coaching staff in weeks to come, even years.
They were too eager. In the first half, it was half-break after half-break, but yet guys with such Test match experience, forced countless offloads that never looked like reaching a player in a black jersey.

Photo: Photosport
Richie Mo’unga, who had a torrid evening, looked short of a gallop and struggled to combine with his backline.
Stand-in captain Beauden Barrett, while largely on the back foot with his forward pack offering little go forward, made poor decisions, more than once.
Asafo Aumua’s overthrown lineouts came back to haunt the All Blacks, as the visitors opted for quick-taps during the second half, with a stumbling lineout in the back of their minds.
All Blacks 2IC Neil Barnes admitted the coaching staff saw different pictures from those on the field, specifically in the final 20 minutes.
“The last one in particular, I know Jason Ryan was f**king yelling at me, 'we should be going to the maul',” Barnes said.
"The leaders on the field decided to do what they're doing, and we'll run with that. But personally, yeah, I'd go into the maul"
Rennie said on Monday at their London hotel that although he hadn’t heard Barnes’ comments, they trust their leaders on the field.
“Yeah, I'm not sure what Barnsey said, but my mindset is I'll let the players decide, and so if we get a penalty, if they kick for goal or kick for a corner or tap, It's based on feel.
“If they feel that, yeah, the opposition is fatigued, that by tapping it we're just going to go again quickly rather than going to the corner and taking 60 seconds to get it in, you've got a win back possession, you bring a referee into the game, versus tapping and playing, and so the amount of opportunities that we left out there, four or five phases into that, we should have profited off.
“We'll often pass down some information, but I'd always leave it for the skipper because they've got a feel. Sometimes it's a scrum, and they're under last warning, so a scrum to bring a ref into the game for a yellow card so I wouldn't say there's a disconnect. It's more that players felt that that was the best option, and I support that.
Why Wales' victory over the All Blacks is the greatest upset ever in international rugby | Mondays with McHardy
But the poor option-taking from the on-field leaders was clear from inside the ground, and at home, I’m sure.
Wallace Sititi went close, but dived over the line and was held up in the process. Seems unlucky, but at what point does it become an All Blacks issue?
With space wide, and one-on-one matchups the All Blacks would have fancied, the on-field decision was to keep it in close, clearly.
With every hit up, it felt like Wales added a defender. The attacking shape, when the All Blacks did go wide, looked frantic, unorganised, and schoolboy like.
They were overawed by the occasion, and the pure emotion Wales were playing with, and lacked the leadership and calmness to make educated decisions on how to break down the red brick wall.
Rennie said he believes he can win the Rugby World Cup next year in Australia with their current game plan and is adamant about it.
Sure, if you get it right, but the All Blacks must develop variation in their attacking game plan that can win differently, against different opponents, in different circumstances.
It’s all on at Twickenham.
Listen to the full review below:

